What are the Differences in the Refractory Materials Used for the Inner Lining of Electric Furnaces?

An electric arc furnace is an electric furnace that uses the energy of an electric arc to smelt metals. Industrially used electric arc furnaces can be divided into three categories: The first category is the direct heating type, where the electric arc occurs between a dedicated electrode rod and the charge being smelted, with the charge directly receiving the heat from the arc. It is mainly used for steelmaking, and also for smelting iron, copper, refractory materials, and refining molten steel. The second category is the indirect heating type, where the electric arc occurs between two dedicated electrode rods, with the charge receiving the radiant heat from the arc. It is used for smelting copper, copper alloys, etc. This type of furnace is noisy and produces poor smelting quality, and has gradually been replaced by other types of furnaces. The third category is called a submerged arc furnace, which uses high-resistivity ore as raw material. During operation, the lower part of the electrodes is generally buried in the charge. Its heating principle utilizes both the heat generated by the resistance of the charge when current passes through it and the heat generated by the electric arc between the electrodes and the charge. Therefore, it is also called an electric arc resistance furnace.

Electric Arc Furnace Wall Structure

The electric arc furnace wall is divided into three parts according to its operating conditions: the main furnace wall, the slag line, and the hot spots.

  • ① In the main furnace wall of high-power and ultra-high-power electric furnaces, directly bonded magnesia-chrome bricks, pre-reacted magnesia-chrome bricks, and magnesia bricks are mainly used.
  • ② The hot spots are close to the electric arc and are subjected to high-temperature radiation and slag splash, resulting in particularly severe damage. Oil-impregnated magnesia bricks, directly bonded magnesia-chrome bricks, cast magnesia-chrome bricks, and magnesia-carbon bricks are mainly used.
  • ③ The slag line is severely corroded by molten steel and slag, and its operating conditions are harsh. Therefore, high-quality refractory materials similar to those used for the hot spots should be used.

Due to the different operating conditions of different parts of the furnace wall, single-material construction is rare. Most furnaces use a combination of various bricks to achieve balanced corrosion. In the upper part of the furnace wall, the slag line and hot spots are weak points due to uneven corrosion caused by heat load, chemical erosion, and mechanical action. These “hot spots” can even limit the service life of the furnace wall. To meet the needs of these harshly corrosive areas, magnesia-carbon bricks, which are resistant to corrosion, thermal shock, and have low linear expansion, are increasingly used in the high-corrosion zones of electric arc furnaces. They have become the preferred refractory material for the walls of UHP electric arc furnaces both domestically and internationally.

Magnesia Chrome Bricks
Magnesia Chrome Bricks

What are the differences in the refractory materials used for the inner lining of electric arc furnaces?

Initially, high-temperature fired direct-bonded magnesia-chrome bricks were used for electric arc furnace walls. In the 1970s, to meet the needs of large electric arc furnaces and the hot spots of UHP (Unified High-Performance) electric arc furnaces, a combination of fused cast magnesia-chrome bricks and rebonded magnesia-chrome bricks was tested. In 1976, “Corhart” fused cast magnesia-chrome bricks were widely used in UHP electric arc furnaces, with 90%–95% used in hot spots and some in the slag line area. Fused cast bricks have a high degree of direct bonding between the magnesia-chrome spinel and the slag, resulting in a dense structure.

The development of electric arc furnace steelmaking in the United States was rapid. A major development that effectively improved the productivity of electric arc furnace steelmaking was the development and use of magnesia-carbon bricks in the high-loss areas of the furnace wall, which had lower raw material and process costs but better performance. These magnesia-carbon bricks were produced from high-purity, high-density sintered magnesia sand with a CaO/SiO2 ratio of 3, containing approximately 10% carbon, with an apparent porosity of 3% and a bulk density greater than 2.95 g/cm³.

In the former Soviet Union, electric arc furnace walls were mostly made of magnesia materials. Reconstituted magnesia-chrome bricks, produced from fused periclase and chromite sand, were tested and used in the severely eroded areas above the taphole of 100t electric arc furnaces. These bricks had few low-melting-point mineral phases, good corrosion resistance, and performed well.

In the UK, electric arc furnace walls generally use ordinary chrome-magnesia bricks (70% chromite, 30% seawater magnesia), fired magnesia-chrome bricks (70% seawater magnesia, 30% chromite), and high-quality magnesia bricks made from seawater magnesia. High-temperature fired magnesia bricks prepared from seawater magnesia or fired magnesia bricks impregnated with pitch and tar were used in hot spots and slag lines, achieving good results.

In Japan, electric arc furnace walls used magnesia-chrome bricks and magnesia bricks. In hot spots, magnesia bricks, magnesia-carbon bricks, cast magnesia-chrome bricks, and carbon bricks were used.

In the 1980s, my country’s electric arc furnace steelmaking developed rapidly, evolving from ordinary power electric arc furnaces to ultra-high power electric arc furnaces. Advances in electric arc furnace (EAF) steelmaking technology are closely linked to the synchronous development of refractory material technology, promoting a steady increase in EAF lifespan and a gradual decrease in refractory material consumption per unit area. My country’s ordinary power EAFs employ two types of linings: one is a monolithic lining made of rammed mortar containing low- and medium-temperature binders in sintered magnesia and fused magnesia; the other is a lining constructed with tar-bonded magnesia bricks and magnesia-carbon bricks of various standards. Alkaline carbonaceous materials are the main materials for furnace wall linings, and magnesia-carbon bricks play a crucial role in EAFs.

Application and Damage Mechanism of Magnesia-Carbon Bricks in Electric Arc Furnaces for Steelmaking

The working environment of electric arc furnace linings is extremely harsh, posing a significant challenge to the lining refractory materials. The two most severe challenges are temperature variations within the furnace and changes in slag composition.

Ordinary electric arc furnace operations complete the melting, oxidation, and reduction stages within the furnace. However, UHP (Ultra-High Power) electric arc furnaces utilize forced melting to significantly increase the melting rate, while alloying is achieved after refining in an LF (Fuel-Fuel-Low Power) furnace. Therefore, the specific power level of UHP electric arc furnaces is generally above 600 kVA per ton of steel, and modern furnaces reach 1000 kVA per ton of steel. The relationship between power level, furnace temperature, and melting time is discussed.

service life of MgO-C bricks in large converters
Magnesia Carbon Bricks

The high power level of UHP electric arc furnaces results in a surface heat load of up to 1000 kVA/m² on the furnace lining. During the melting period, the furnace lining is rarely shielded, and combined with the highest radiation levels, this creates a hot spot on the lining opposite the electric arc. The minimum heat load occurs between phases, in the “cold zone,” and the difference in heat load between the hot and cold zones can reach 60%. This demonstrates the spatial unevenness of temperature within the electric arc furnace. Under these conditions, some hot zones can reach temperatures exceeding 2000℃. This is extremely detrimental to the slag resistance of magnesia-carbon bricks, as slag penetrates these hot spots and erodes the entire brick structure. Furthermore, temperature differences increase internal thermal stress within the brick, making it prone to spalling under the mechanical erosion of the slag.

Another characteristic of electric arc furnace steelmaking is the wide variety of steel grades produced. This variety results in diverse slag composition and properties, making the slag erosion on the MgO-C bricks of the furnace wall extremely complex. The intense boiling of molten steel and slag, the stirring, and the thermal shock from the electric arc cause the furnace lining to experience far more severe erosion than in a converter. Consequently, while the service life of MgO-C bricks in large converters reaches thousands or even tens of thousands of heats (using slag splashing protection technology), the service life of electric arc furnace walls remains only 300-500 heats. The composition of primary and final slag from smelting the same steel grade can vary significantly depending on changes in smelting parameters. The variation in composition is even more pronounced when smelting primary and final slag from different steel grades. Similar to the situation with slag in converter processes, the most significant variation is primarily in binary basicity.

Traditional electric arc furnace steelmaking processes encompass the entire melting-refining process, with each furnace lasting 3-4 hours. The composition of the slag and reducing slag varies significantly during the oxidation and reduction phases. For the furnace lining refractory materials, this involves alternating erosion by acidic and basic slags. For example, in 1Cr18Ni19Ti steel, the initial slag has a C/S ratio <1, while the final slag has a ratio >2. Electron probe microanalysis has been used to thoroughly study the phase combinations and chemical composition changes of the molten pool slag and splashed slag during different smelting cycles in traditional steelmaking processes. While the percentage content of each phase cannot be determined to estimate the overall slag composition, changes in phase chemical composition can still reveal variations in the overall slag composition. The melting and oxidation phases produce oxidizing slag; the refining and alloying phases produce reducing slag. Except for some characteristic elements of special alloy steels, the phase combinations in these slags follow normal patterns. However, the micro-regional composition of the phases allows analysis of their crystallization behavior. For instance, the banded structure and compositional changes of spinel in the molten pool slag are due to variations in slag composition during the smelting cycle. This also reflects the cation substitution during spinel nucleation and growth, changing from a high-chromium type to a high-alumina type, which is also a characteristic of the chromium return and deoxidation process. During the oxidation period, the spinel remains high-chromium, while during the refining-alloying period, it becomes high-FeOn type.

The erosion of magnesia-carbon bricks occurs under the alternating and cyclical action of various slag compositions. In each furnace run, for each heat of steel, and even at different smelting stages within a single heat, the erosion behavior of the magnesia-carbon brick working surface changes. From changes in slag basicity to changes in slag oxidizability, and even changes in slag fluidity, these changes all have different effects on the erosion of magnesia-carbon bricks.

 

Development of Low-Carbon Magnesia-Carbon Bricks

The carbon content in traditional magnesia carbon bricks is relatively high, generally in the range of 10-20%. Due to the presence of carbon in magnesia-carbon bricks, the performance of magnesia-carbon bricks is greatly improved, making them superior to magnesia-chrome bricks and magnesia-dolomite bricks in certain properties. However, due to the progress of metallurgical technology and the demanding requirements for refractory materials, a series of problems have appeared in the use of traditional magnesia-carbon bricks. For example, the excellent thermal conductivity of graphite increases the heat loss in the steelmaking process and wastes energy. Too high graphite content will increase the carbon content in the molten steel during the refining process outside the furnace, affect the quality of the molten steel, and is not conducive to the reduction of the carbon content in the steel. In addition, graphite is a precious non-renewable resource, and traditional magnesia carbon bricks rely too much on graphite, which is detrimental to the sustainable use of resources.

Rongsheng High-Quality Magnesia Carbon Bricks
Rongsheng High-Quality Magnesia Carbon Bricks

However, simply reducing the graphite content in the magnesia carbon brick will not only reduce the thermal conductivity of the magnesia carbon brick but also increase the elastic modulus of the magnesia carbon brick, which will reduce the thermal shock stability of the material. In addition, due to the low wettability of graphite with molten steel and molten slag, if the graphite content in the magnesia carbon brick is reduced, the magnesia carbon brick will be more easily corroded by molten steel and molten slag, resulting in a decrease in the corrosion resistance of the material. Therefore, research on magnesia carbon bricks with lower graphite content and excellent thermal shock stability, and slag erosion resistance has become the focus of current research and a new direction for the future development of magnesia carbon bricks.

Low Carbon Magnesia Carbon Brick with High Performance
Low Carbon Magnesia Carbon Brick with High Performance

In order to solve these contradictions and improve the performance of low-carbon magnesia-carbon bricks, we can start with improving the carbon structure of the combined carbon, optimizing the matrix, and using high-efficiency antioxidants. The specific improvement measures are as follows.

(1) Modified magnesia particles

In order to solve the poor thermal exfoliation of low-carbon magnesia-carbon bricks, a thin asphalt coating is prepared on the surface of the magnesia particles to reduce the thermal expansion of the magnesia particles during use. In this way, the thermal shock stability of low-carbon magnesia-carbon bricks can be improved.

(2) Change the type of carbon source and the particle size of graphite

By adding a small amount of carbon black (carbon black is a mixture of single spherical carbon black and polymeric carbon black), magnesia carbon bricks show outstanding excellent properties, such as reduction of elastic modulus, and relaxation of thermal stress between different particles. Improve the thermal shock stability and corrosion resistance of low-carbon magnesia-carbon bricks.

A small amount of nano-sized carbon is added to make the new magnesia carbon brick with a carbon content of about half of the ordinary magnesia carbon brick still have excellent performance. Adding different amounts of nano-sized carbon has different effects on performance. The practice has proved that adding 0.9wt% of nano-sized carbon and 3wt% of graphite as a mixed carbon source makes the material have the best performance.

(3) Modified binder

The magnesia-carbon bricks after adding the nano-sized matrix, on the one hand, reduce the carbon content and at the same time ensure the thermal shock stability of the material, on the other hand, reduce the heat loss of the converter. The composite bonding agent increases the degree of graphitization after carbonization of the bonding agent, forms micropores in the matrix, and improves the mechanical properties of the magnesia carbon brick at room temperature, high temperature, and other mechanical properties.

(4) Highly effective antioxidants

Low-carbon magnesia-carbon bricks with special additives have the same thermal shock stability as traditional magnesia-carbon bricks.

To purchase high-quality magnesia-carbon bricks and low-carbon magnesia-carbon bricks, please contact refractory manufacturers.

How To Find The Difference Between Carbon Bricks And Magnesia Carbon Bricks

Magnesia Carbon Bricks - Rongsheng Refractory Bricks

Have you ever wondered exactly what the difference was between carbon bricks and magnesia carbon bricks? If this is a new topic of interest to you, it may be rather hard to understand. In fact, for a topic of this nature, you may not even know where to begin your research. However, with the internet, it is not at all difficult to find out the information you need. By the same token, it can be hard to decide where to begin to find that information. We are going to inform you of three venues that can help you begin your search for information about carbon bricks and magnesia carbon bricks.

Magnesia Carbon Bricks - Rongsheng Refractory Bricks
Magnesia Carbon Bricks

Search Engine Friendly

Perhaps one of the best if not most logical steps for finding the information you need about carbon bricks and magnesia carbon bricks is through one of the online search engines. By using either Google, Bing, or one of the others, you sill have no trouble finding exactly what you want. All that is required is searching for the topic in this case, carbon bricks and magnesia carbon bricks, and placing it in quotes. This is going to help bring back all of the most relevant searches first that have that topic contained within it. Additionally, one may also use the power of the internet to find a Wikiguide about this said topic.

Carbon Bricks - Rongsheng Refractory Bricks
Carbon Bricks

Wiki Search

In this case, you will still need to use a search engine, but you are looking for specific information from one of the giant WIki sites. Many times, you will find the information you need through Wikipedia. However, in the case of carbon bricks and magnesia carbon bricks, you may have better luck with a wiki devoted to this topic. To find the information you need, you are going to go to a search engine and type in the following phrase “carbon bricks and magnesia carbon bricks + wiki”. This will bring up a listing of the most relevant wikis that should have the exact information you require. Furthermore, you may want to search through article directories for precise information.

Article Directories

In the past, article directories were a veritable wealth of knowledge. However, they were abused and filled with a lot of spam and poorly written articles. While they are not as popular as they once were, they still contain a great deal of information. In fact, it is possible to find out everything you need to know without ever leaving the directory. Perhaps one of the biggest and best to this day is Ezinearticles. It is well worth a visit to see if there is any information you may be able to find from that site that will help in your research.

All things considered, using one or all of these methods should give you the knowledge that you desire. Take your time and follow through and find a method that you enjoy the most. We hope that these tips will allow you to find out all you need to about carbon bricks and magnesia carbon bricks.